Перевести страницу на:  
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Библиотека
ваш профиль

Вернуться к содержанию

Международное право и международные организации / International Law and International Organizations
Правильная ссылка на статью:

Fatmir Tartale, Gerti Tartale Historical development of the оrganization of the criminal justice system in Albania and its European integration

Аннотация: The study and analysis of the legal system in Albania in its entirety and in particular the criminal one is important firstly for the citizens of this country, in the fight against crime in general and against organized crime in particular, to protect them and guarantee the right to a better and more peaceful life. Secondly, it is beneficial in terms of doctrine but also practice, being the backbone of democracy and the rule of law. In the context of its historical development, during these hundred years in Albania there have been judicial institutions that responded to different developments, according to state formations, from antiquity up to the fourth century in Illyria, to the present, when we were free or occupied by different invaders in years, foreign and Albanian legislations have been implemented. Starting with the Albanian customary law like the Kanun of Lek Dukagjin, that of Laberia, of Skanderbeg, of the Mountains, followed by the Sharia Law, the Ottoman Criminal Code, the Ottoman Criminal Procedure Code, which adopted the model of the Napoleonic Code of 1808, the Kanun of the Elderly of 1913, the Prince Vid Act on Judicial Organization of 1914, the King Zog Criminal Code, laws on the functioning of the criminal legal system, etc. Based on these acts of the Albanian customary law, on the Albanian and foreign legislation, the functions of the powers of courts were assigned, as well as their composition, establishing the criteria to be a judge, as well as the implementation of a criminal proceeding, judgment, decision and its execution, voluntary or forced, as rendered by the court. Even during the war, until 1944, the legal system of justice operated in pursuance of the legislation of the invading countries or the Albanian legislation in force at the time. From 1944 to 1990, the legal system of criminal justice functioned referring to the post-war laws, the Criminal Code, the Criminal Procedure Code, the Civil Code and the Civil Procedure Code in force for several years, even with the amendments that have been subsequently made. Upon the amendments made to these basic laws and infrastructure stemming from their implementation, the rights of litigants were increasingly restricted, attaching priority to the executive and those who raised charges to the court, removing protection and trying the defendants, without a defense counsel, disadvantaging and unbalancing him, in relation to the prosecuting party, the prosecutor, who was in the service of the state of the proletariat dictatorship. From 1990 to 2012, with the advent of the democratic system in Albania and the victory of the democratic forces, the legal system of criminal justice has been reformed. It continues to be reformed, while respecting the principles of the functioning of a democratic state, like the separation of powers, judicial independence and the right to a fair trial. This reform is carried out consistently, through the development and adoption of the Constitution of the Republic of Albania and different codes, like the Criminal Code, the Criminal Procedure Code, the Civil Code, the Civil Procedure Code, the Law on the Prosecutor’s Office, the Judicial Police, for execution of court decisions, etc.. These laws are in line with the EU democratic countries’ laws, and beyond, which like the European countries’ laws are implemented to develop a due legal process, by equality of arms, precisely reflecting the European Convention of Human Rights «.1)


Ключевые слова:

History, development, organization, criminal justice, Judicial Organization, legal system, Albania, European integration, european law.

Abstract: As the authors point out, the study and analysis of the legal system in Albania in its entirety and in particular the criminal one is important in the fight against crime in general and against organized crime in particular, to protect the people and guarantee them the right to a better and more peaceful life. It is beneficial in terms of doctrine but also practice, being the backbone of democracy and the rule of law. In the context of its historical development, during these hundred years in Albania there have been judicial institutions that responded to different developments, according to state formations, from antiquity up to the fourth century in Illyria, to the present, when foreign and Albanian legislations have been implemented. The article concerns organization of system of criminal justice in Albania since 1912 to the current time, as well as the changes towards the European integration and the judicial reforms.


Keywords:

jurisprudence, law, Albania, criminal law, crime, court, rule of law, integration.


Эта статья может быть бесплатно загружена в формате PDF для чтения. Обращаем ваше внимание на необходимость соблюдения авторских прав, указания библиографической ссылки на статью при цитировании.

Скачать статью

Библиография
1. European Convention of Human Rights, Tirana, 2011, page.10
2. Halim Islami “Demokratizimi i organizimit gjyqesor ne Shqiperi” (Democratization of judicial organization in Albania), Tirana, 2000, page 13
3. Koco Nova “Zhvillimi i organizimit gjyqesor ne Shqiperi” (“Development of judicial organization in Albania”), Tirana, 1982, page 61
4. Kanuni i Zhurise (Kanun of the Elderly) Tirana, 2009, page.5
5. Law No.9877,dated 18 February 2008 “On organization of the judicial power in Albania”
6. Koco Nova “Zhvillimi i organizimit gjyqesor ne Shqiperi” (Development of judicial organization in Albania), Tirana, 1982, page.68
7. Statute of the Republic, Article 9
8. “Kushtetutat” Statuti Themeltar i Mbreterise Shqiptare”, (Constitutions, Fundamental Statute of the Albanian Kingdom), Tirana, 2006, articles 118-140, page.230
9. Official Journal No.5, dated 16 February 1925
10. “Kushtetutat” Statuti Themeltar i Mbreterise Shqiptare, (Constitutions, Fundamental Statute of the Albanian Kingdom), Tirana, 2006, article 126, page.231
11. Official Journal No.19 dated 11 May 1925
12. Albanian Criminal Code, Tirana, 1929
13. Official Journal No.4,Tirana, 1937
14. Criminal Procedure Code of the Socialist Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1982
15. Criminal Procedure Code of the Socialist Republic of Albania,Tirana, 1982, page 578
16. Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania, articles 400-407,Tirana, 2010
17. Law No.59 dated 17 May 1945 “On provisional judicial organization”
18. Law No.59 dated 17 May 1945 “On elections of popular judges”
19. “Kushtetutat”, Kushtetuta e Republikes Popullore e Shqiperise (Constitutions, Fundamental Statute of the Albanian Kingdom), Tirana, 2006
20. Koco Nova ”Zhvillimi i organizimit gjyqesor ne Shqiperi” (Development of judicial organization in Albania),Tirana, 1982,page.125
21. Law No.239 date 5 December 1946 “On organization and powers of military courts”
22. Law No.1284, dated 9 June 1951 “On judicial organization”, as amended by Decree No.1778, dated 3 December 1963 and Decree No.2226, 3365,dated 6 November 1961.
23. Law No.4406,dated 24 June 1968 “On judicial organization”
24. Criminal Code of the People’s Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1952
25. Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1953
26. Halim Islami “Demokratizimi i legjislacionit penal” (Democratization of criminal legislation), Tirana, 2000
27. Constitution of the People’s Socialist Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1976
28. Law No. 6298, dated 27 March 1981 “On the Prosecutor’s Office of the People’s Socialist Republic of Albania”
29. Law No.7174, dated 1 February 1988 “On judicial organization of the Republic of Albania”
30. Law 7491 dated 29 April 1991 “On main constitutional provisions”
31. Law No.7535, dated 17 December 1991 “On some amendments and additions to Law No.7174 dated 1 February 1988 “On judicial organization”
32. Law No.7561 ,dated 29 April 1992 “On some amendments and additions to Law No.7491 dated 29 April 1991 “On main constitutional provisions”
33. Criminal Code, Criminal Procedure Code, Civil Code, Albanian Civil Procedure Code, Tirana, 1995
34. Constitution of the Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1998
35. Law No.9877 dated 18 February 22008 “On organization of the judicial power in the Republic of Albania”
36. Constitution of the Republic of Albania, article 145, Tirana, 2010.
37. MAPO Newspaper, 17 February 2011.
38. Law No.8678 dated 14.05.2001 “On Organization and Functioning of the Ministry of Justice”, as amended.
39. Law No. 9877 dated 18.02.2008 “On Organization of the Judicial Power in the Republic of Albania”.
40. Decision No.14, dated 22.05.2006 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania.
41. Law No.9877 dated 18.02.2008 “On Organization of the Judicial Power in the Republic of Albania”.
42. Law No.88/2012 “On some amendments to Law No. 8417, dated 21 October 1980, Constitution of the Republic of Albania, approved on 18.09.2012, promulgated by decree of the President of the Republic No.7779 dated 9.10.2012 of.
43. Decision No. 21, dated 07.06.2007 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania
44. HCJ Decision 175/2, dated 28.04.2005.
45. European Convention of Human Rights, Publication of the Council of Europe, Tirana, 2011
46. Decision No.29 dated 30.04.2001 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania.
47. Decision No.11,dated 02.04.2003 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania.
48. Decision No.16, dated 27.04.2007 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania.
49. Law No.8588, dated 15.03.2000 “On organization and functioning of the High Court”.
50. Law No.8811, dated 17.05.2001 “On organization and functioning of the High Council of Justice”.
51. Criminal Procedure, co-authors, page.55, Tirana, 2007.
52. Civil Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania, article 35, Tirana, 2011.
53. Criminal Procedure Code of the People’s Socialist Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1982.
54. Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania, Tirana, 2011.
55. Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania,Tirana, 2011.
56. Procedura Penale. Oreste Dominioni.Permaria Corso,Alfredo Gaito ,Giorgio Spangher,Giovani Dean. Gulio Garuti.Oliviero Mazza. F.485,Turin, 2010
57. Magjistratura në demokracinë bashkëkohore (System of Magistrates in the modern democracy), C. Guarnieri, P. Pederzoli, Tirana, 200
References
1. European Convention of Human Rights, Tirana, 2011, page.10
2. Halim Islami “Demokratizimi i organizimit gjyqesor ne Shqiperi” (Democratization of judicial organization in Albania), Tirana, 2000, page 13
3. Koco Nova “Zhvillimi i organizimit gjyqesor ne Shqiperi” (“Development of judicial organization in Albania”), Tirana, 1982, page 61
4. Kanuni i Zhurise (Kanun of the Elderly) Tirana, 2009, page.5
5. Law No.9877,dated 18 February 2008 “On organization of the judicial power in Albania”
6. Koco Nova “Zhvillimi i organizimit gjyqesor ne Shqiperi” (Development of judicial organization in Albania), Tirana, 1982, page.68
7. Statute of the Republic, Article 9
8. “Kushtetutat” Statuti Themeltar i Mbreterise Shqiptare”, (Constitutions, Fundamental Statute of the Albanian Kingdom), Tirana, 2006, articles 118-140, page.230
9. Official Journal No.5, dated 16 February 1925
10. “Kushtetutat” Statuti Themeltar i Mbreterise Shqiptare, (Constitutions, Fundamental Statute of the Albanian Kingdom), Tirana, 2006, article 126, page.231
11. Official Journal No.19 dated 11 May 1925
12. Albanian Criminal Code, Tirana, 1929
13. Official Journal No.4,Tirana, 1937
14. Criminal Procedure Code of the Socialist Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1982
15. Criminal Procedure Code of the Socialist Republic of Albania,Tirana, 1982, page 578
16. Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania, articles 400-407,Tirana, 2010
17. Law No.59 dated 17 May 1945 “On provisional judicial organization”
18. Law No.59 dated 17 May 1945 “On elections of popular judges”
19. “Kushtetutat”, Kushtetuta e Republikes Popullore e Shqiperise (Constitutions, Fundamental Statute of the Albanian Kingdom), Tirana, 2006
20. Koco Nova ”Zhvillimi i organizimit gjyqesor ne Shqiperi” (Development of judicial organization in Albania),Tirana, 1982,page.125
21. Law No.239 date 5 December 1946 “On organization and powers of military courts”
22. Law No.1284, dated 9 June 1951 “On judicial organization”, as amended by Decree No.1778, dated 3 December 1963 and Decree No.2226, 3365,dated 6 November 1961.
23. Law No.4406,dated 24 June 1968 “On judicial organization”
24. Criminal Code of the People’s Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1952
25. Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1953
26. Halim Islami “Demokratizimi i legjislacionit penal” (Democratization of criminal legislation), Tirana, 2000
27. Constitution of the People’s Socialist Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1976
28. Law No. 6298, dated 27 March 1981 “On the Prosecutor’s Office of the People’s Socialist Republic of Albania”
29. Law No.7174, dated 1 February 1988 “On judicial organization of the Republic of Albania”
30. Law 7491 dated 29 April 1991 “On main constitutional provisions”
31. Law No.7535, dated 17 December 1991 “On some amendments and additions to Law No.7174 dated 1 February 1988 “On judicial organization”
32. Law No.7561 ,dated 29 April 1992 “On some amendments and additions to Law No.7491 dated 29 April 1991 “On main constitutional provisions”
33. Criminal Code, Criminal Procedure Code, Civil Code, Albanian Civil Procedure Code, Tirana, 1995
34. Constitution of the Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1998
35. Law No.9877 dated 18 February 22008 “On organization of the judicial power in the Republic of Albania”
36. Constitution of the Republic of Albania, article 145, Tirana, 2010.
37. MAPO Newspaper, 17 February 2011.
38. Law No.8678 dated 14.05.2001 “On Organization and Functioning of the Ministry of Justice”, as amended.
39. Law No. 9877 dated 18.02.2008 “On Organization of the Judicial Power in the Republic of Albania”.
40. Decision No.14, dated 22.05.2006 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania.
41. Law No.9877 dated 18.02.2008 “On Organization of the Judicial Power in the Republic of Albania”.
42. Law No.88/2012 “On some amendments to Law No. 8417, dated 21 October 1980, Constitution of the Republic of Albania, approved on 18.09.2012, promulgated by decree of the President of the Republic No.7779 dated 9.10.2012 of.
43. Decision No. 21, dated 07.06.2007 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania
44. HCJ Decision 175/2, dated 28.04.2005.
45. European Convention of Human Rights, Publication of the Council of Europe, Tirana, 2011
46. Decision No.29 dated 30.04.2001 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania.
47. Decision No.11,dated 02.04.2003 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania.
48. Decision No.16, dated 27.04.2007 of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Albania.
49. Law No.8588, dated 15.03.2000 “On organization and functioning of the High Court”.
50. Law No.8811, dated 17.05.2001 “On organization and functioning of the High Council of Justice”.
51. Criminal Procedure, co-authors, page.55, Tirana, 2007.
52. Civil Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania, article 35, Tirana, 2011.
53. Criminal Procedure Code of the People’s Socialist Republic of Albania, Tirana, 1982.
54. Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania, Tirana, 2011.
55. Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Albania,Tirana, 2011.
56. Procedura Penale. Oreste Dominioni.Permaria Corso,Alfredo Gaito ,Giorgio Spangher,Giovani Dean. Gulio Garuti.Oliviero Mazza. F.485,Turin, 2010
57. Magjistratura në demokracinë bashkëkohore (System of Magistrates in the modern democracy), C. Guarnieri, P. Pederzoli, Tirana, 200